Regulation•

Federal Judge Clears Peraire-Bueno Brothers of Every Charge Over the 12-Second, $25 Million Ethereum Bot Trade

Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and money laundering conspiracy, finding prosecutors never proved a material misrepresentation in the 2023 Ethereum trade.

Written By :MINRK
Federal Judge Clears Peraire-Bueno Brothers of Every Charge Over the 12-Second, $25 Million Ethereum Bot Trade

Photo by Sasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash

Mentioned in This Article

ETH
ETH
Ethereum
$1,808.86
0.86%

1. Ethereum MEV case closes with acquittal on all counts

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers accused of taking $25 million from automated trading bots on Ethereum (ETH) in April 2023, were acquitted of all charges on Monday, November 16, 2026. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke of Manhattan federal court granted their motion for a judgment of acquittal, closing the Ethereum MEV case without a second trial.

The decision removes three counts at once: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. It arrives roughly a year after the brothers' first trial ended without a verdict, when jurors in Manhattan could not agree and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025.

A judgment of acquittal is a ruling by the judge, rather than a jury, that the evidence presented by the government is not enough to sustain a conviction. In this instance it means the prosecution is over. The brothers will not face a new jury on these charges, and the criminal case that began with their arrest in May 2024 has reached its end.

The outcome matters well beyond the two defendants. The prosecution was one of the first attempts to apply a long-standing federal fraud statute to the way transactions are ordered inside Ethereum blocks, a technical corner of the network where automated traders compete against each other with few formal rules. Clarke's ruling describes the matter as a "first of its kind" prosecution, a label the government itself chose when it wrote the indictment.

2. Why did the judge acquit the Peraire-Bueno brothers?

Clarke acquitted the brothers because, in her view, prosecutors did not prove the one element that a wire fraud conviction cannot do without: a material misrepresentation. None of the theories the government put forward established that the defendants had made a false statement or representation of the kind the statute requires.

The judge was careful about the limits of that conclusion. She wrote that the question before the court was not whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral, and not whether it might have broken laws that prosecutors never charged. The only issue was whether the evidence satisfied the specific legal test for wire fraud, and she found that it did not.

Central to her reasoning was the nature of the environment in which the trade took place. Clarke described Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." In a setting like that, participants do not sign agreements with one another or accept a rulebook before they transact, which makes it harder to identify a promise or statement that someone relied on and that turned out to be false.

Clarke accepted that what the brothers did "may have frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost, the software at the center of the episode. That, she concluded, was not sufficient to make the conduct fraud. Going against the intended purpose of a piece of software is a different thing from deceiving a counterparty through a material misstatement, and only the latter supports the charge the government brought.

3. What is MEV on Ethereum?

MEV stands for maximal extractable value, the profit that can be captured by controlling which transactions go into a block and in what order. On Ethereum, pending transactions are visible before they are finalized, so anyone who can influence their sequence can trade around other users and keep the difference.

The best-known technique is the sandwich. A bot spots a pending trade that is large enough to move a token's price, places its own purchase just ahead of it and its own sale just behind it, and pockets the gap. The user in the middle receives a worse price than they otherwise would have. The automated traders that run this strategy are commonly called sandwich bots, and they were the targets of the April 2023 trade.

MEV-Boost is the software that organizes much of this activity. It lets Ethereum validators, the participants who propose new blocks, hand the job of arranging transactions to specialized block builders. Builders compete to assemble the most valuable block, and validators select from what is offered. Relays sit between the two groups and pass blocks along, so that a validator commits to a block before seeing the full detail of what is inside it.

That arrangement depends on software behaving as designed rather than on contracts between the parties. It is the reason the judge's description of the network as trustless and adversarial carries so much weight in her analysis: the system is built on the assumption that every participant is trying to out-trade every other one.

4. How the trade unfolded in about 12 seconds

The court's ruling sets out the mechanics of what happened in April 2023. The brothers first placed bait transactions, trades constructed so that particular sandwich bots would find them attractive and move to trade around them.

The bots responded as expected and bundled their own trades with the bait. At that point, according to the ruling, the brothers took advantage of a bug in a relay's code. The flaw let them see the bots' bundled trades before the block containing them had been committed, information that would ordinarily have stayed hidden until it was too late to act on.

With that view of the bots' positions, the brothers replaced their bait transactions with different ones that sold the tokens instead. The bots, which had bought in anticipation of a profitable sandwich, were left holding the losing side. They lost about $25 million, and the whole sequence took roughly 12 seconds, the length of a single Ethereum block interval.

The victims were therefore not ordinary retail users but automated programs whose own business is to profit from the ordering of other people's transactions. That fact did not decide the case, but it shaped the debate around it from the start, since the conduct involved one set of sophisticated traders turning the tables on another.

5. From the 2024 arrests to a deadlocked jury

Authorities took the pair into custody in May 2024, a little over a year after the trade. At the time, they said the brothers had spent months preparing the operation and had then taken steps to conceal the proceeds, allegations that formed the basis of the fraud and money laundering counts.

The case went to trial in Manhattan in 2025. Jurors heard from an insider who testified that the brothers had allegedly planned the attack. Before the trial, the defense had tried to keep evidence of the brothers' Google searches away from the jury.

After the evidence was presented, the jury could not reach a unanimous decision. Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025, which left the charges pending and the possibility of a second trial open. The defense motion for acquittal asked the judge to rule that the government's evidence could not support a conviction as a matter of law, and Monday's decision granted that request in full.

6. Money laundering count falls with the fraud charges

The third charge did not survive on its own. The money laundering conspiracy count depended on the $25 million being the proceeds of the alleged wire fraud. Laundering charges of this kind require an underlying crime that generated the money being moved or hidden.

Once Clarke found that prosecutors had not proved wire fraud, there was no underlying offense left to supply those proceeds. The laundering count therefore fell together with the two fraud counts, leaving nothing in the indictment for a second jury to consider.

This structure explains why a single legal finding, the absence of a material misrepresentation, was enough to dispose of the entire case. All three counts rested on the same foundation, and when it gave way, each of them went with it.

7. A due process concern the court left undecided

One further point appears in a footnote to the ruling. Clarke wrote that the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns," a reference to the constitutional principle that people must have fair notice of what conduct is criminal before they can be punished for it.

She did not go on to rule on that question. Because the failure to prove a material misrepresentation was already enough to acquit, the court had no need to decide whether the prosecution was also flawed on constitutional grounds, and the judge declined to do so.

The footnote nonetheless records the court's unease about applying a fraud statute to a novel setting in which, by the judge's own description, there are no terms of use. It sits alongside her statement that the brothers' conduct may have run against the spirit of MEV-Boost without amounting to a crime under the charges filed.

8. What the ruling means for the crypto industry

The crypto industry followed the case closely from the moment the arrests were announced, because it tested how far existing fraud law reaches into the competitive, automated world of block construction. Developers, validators and trading firms all operate in the space the indictment described.

Clarke's decision answers a narrow question. It holds that, on the evidence presented against these two defendants, the government did not show the material misrepresentation that wire fraud demands. It does not declare the brothers' conduct acceptable, and the judge said explicitly that morality and uncharged offenses were outside what she had to decide.

What the decision does establish is that exploiting a software bug to gain an advantage over other traders in a trustless system is not automatically wire fraud. Prosecutors still have to point to a false statement or representation that mattered, and in an environment with no terms of use, the judge found none of the government's theories met that standard.

For Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the practical result is simple. After an arrest in May 2024, a trial in 2025 that ended with a hung jury and a year of uncertainty over a possible retrial, the prosecution against them is finished.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY