Regulation•

Permanent Rules for Tokenized Stock Trading Will Not Be Proposed Before 2027, SEC Markets Director Jamie Selway Says

SEC trading and markets director Jamie Selway expects a 2027 proposal for permanent tokenized stock rules and would not rule out covering tokenized derivatives.

Written By :MINRK
Permanent Rules for Tokenized Stock Trading Will Not Be Proposed Before 2027, SEC Markets Director Jamie Selway Says

Photo by Sartre LIU on Unsplash

1. SEC tokenized stocks rule proposal is expected in 2027

Jamie Selway, director of the Securities and Exchange Commission's Division of Trading and Markets, said on November 16, 2026, that a proposal for permanent SEC tokenized stocks rules has 'got to be a 2027 event.' Speaking on a livestream hosted by Laura Shin, he said his division is framing the rules that would replace the agency's five-year innovation exemption.

Selway gave the timeline when asked when final rules could be expected. His first answer was that it was 'hard to say.' He then narrowed the estimate, tying the 2027 date specifically to getting a proposal out rather than to finishing the rulemaking. He also stressed that he was offering his own views, and not those of the chairman, the commissioners, the commission as a whole or the staff of his division.

The Division of Trading and Markets is the part of the SEC responsible for the rules that govern how securities are traded, including oversight of exchanges and broker-dealers. That makes it the natural home for any framework covering tokenized shares, and it gives weight to its director's view of the schedule even when he speaks in a personal capacity.

The distinction between a proposal and a final rule matters. In a typical SEC rulemaking, the agency publishes a proposed rule, invites public comment, reviews the responses and only then votes on a final version. A proposal in 2027 therefore marks the start of the formal process, and the permanent framework itself would arrive later.

2. What is the SEC's innovation exemption for tokenized stocks?

The innovation exemption is a five-year order the SEC issued on September 17 that allows 'tokenized securities venues' to trade tokenized versions of listed stocks without registering as exchanges. The permanent rules Selway described are intended to take its place.

A tokenized stock is a share of a company represented as a token on a blockchain. Under the exemption, trading in these tokens runs through automated market makers. An automated market maker is software that holds reserves of assets in a pool and quotes prices based on those reserves, instead of matching individual buyers and sellers through an order book as a conventional exchange does. The order also restricts who can take part: only approved users are allowed to trade in the pools.

Supporters of tokenization argue that putting shares on a blockchain can allow trading and settlement to happen on the same system and outside the hours kept by traditional markets. Those claims are part of what the exemption period is meant to test. The order does not change what a share is. It changes the type of venue on which a tokenized version of that share may lawfully trade.

The arrangement gives firms a way to operate a new kind of trading venue for equities under SEC oversight while the agency observes how the model performs. Registering as a national securities exchange is a demanding process built around traditional market structure, and the exemption sets that requirement aside for qualifying venues for a limited period.

3. Why the exemption runs for five years

A fixed expiry date was a deliberate design choice, in Selway's telling. He said the five-year limit keeps the SEC committed to permanent rulemaking once it has learned what works. A temporary order with an end date creates an obligation to follow through, because the venues operating under it will eventually need a lasting legal basis.

He does not expect to use the full five years before acting. Selway said he hopes to move from the exemption to rulemaking within about a year. That is consistent with his 2027 estimate for a proposal, given that the order was issued in mid-September.

The sequence he outlined is to let the market operate under the exemption, study the results and then write rules informed by what has been observed. That approach differs from drafting a comprehensive rule in advance and requiring firms to fit their products to it. It also means the early experience of the first venues will shape the permanent framework, which raises the stakes for how those launches go.

4. Tokenized derivatives are not ruled out

The current order has a narrow scope. It covers only tokens that carry the full rights of the underlying share. That requirement excludes synthetic tokens, which track the price of a stock without giving the holder the share itself.

Selway signaled that the permanent rules could go further. He said he 'certainly wouldn't foreclose' the possibility of those rules extending to tokenized derivatives. A derivative is a contract whose value is derived from another asset, and a synthetic stock token functions in that way: its holder is exposed to the stock's price movements but does not own the equity.

The gap between the two product types is more than technical. A token carrying full rights puts its holder in the position of a shareholder, entitled to whatever the share itself provides. A synthetic token provides economic exposure only, and its value depends on the issuer continuing to honor the arrangement. Rules written for the first category would not automatically suit the second, which is why extending the framework to derivatives would be a distinct policy decision.

The remark is not a commitment, and it came with the same caveat that Selway was speaking for himself. It does, however, indicate that the question of synthetic products remains open inside the division as it works out what the lasting framework should include. For firms that have built or are considering price-tracking tokens, the scope of the eventual proposal is one of the most consequential details still to be settled.

5. Selway on offshore synthetic stock tokens

Access by US investors to synthetic stock tokens on unregistered venues overseas drew a direct response. Selway called that activity 'not compliant' and said the SEC could act.

He paired the warning with a description of the agency's current priorities. Under SEC Chairman Paul Atkins, he said, the commission has concentrated on building markets in the United States rather than pursuing offshore ones. The exemption fits that approach, since it is designed to give tokenized stock trading a regulated home onshore.

That emphasis does not amount to indifference. If investors are harmed offshore, Selway said, 'we'd take a look.' The message to market participants is that the agency's first preference is to bring activity into its own framework, but that enforcement remains available where US investors are hurt.

6. Securitize's Brett Redfearn argues against synthetic tokens

Not everyone in the industry wants the rules widened to cover synthetics. Brett Redfearn, president of the tokenization firm Securitize, made the case against them when he appeared on the same program in September.

His central objection is counterparty risk. A synthetic token is a claim on whoever issued it, not on the company whose stock it tracks. If the issuer runs into trouble, Redfearn said, the token holder 'isn't holding anything anymore.' An investor who owns an actual share, by contrast, keeps that ownership regardless of what happens to an intermediary.

Redfearn also opposes tokens that drop dividends or voting rights. Those are standard entitlements of share ownership, and a token that omits them delivers less than the stock it is modeled on. He told Shin that tokenization should improve things for investors, a standard that a product with fewer rights than ordinary shares would not meet.

The disagreement sets out the policy choice facing the SEC. One position holds that only tokens conferring full shareholder rights belong in the regulated market, which is the line the current exemption draws. The other, which Selway declined to close off, would allow price-tracking instruments to be covered by permanent rules as well.

7. OKXICE is due to open on November 23

The first major test of the exemption is close. OKXICE, a venue run by the crypto exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange, the owner of the New York Stock Exchange, plans to open under the order on November 23.

The launch follows objections from dozens of companies to having their shares listed on the venue. Their resistance raises a question the exemption brings to the surface: how much say an issuer should have over whether its stock is tokenized and traded on a new type of platform.

The pairing behind the venue is notable in its own right. It joins a crypto-native exchange with the operator of the best-known stock exchange in the United States, bringing together a firm experienced in blockchain-based trading and one rooted in traditional equity markets. How such a venue performs under the exemption is likely to be among the first pieces of evidence available to the division.

Selway declined to draw conclusions from that reaction. He said it is 'extremely early' to judge the response. With the venue not yet open, there is no trading record to assess, and the division's stated plan is to learn from how the exemption operates in practice before writing permanent rules.

8. What happens next

Two dates frame the period ahead. The nearest is November 23, when OKXICE is scheduled to begin operating under the exemption. The second is 2027, when Selway expects his division to put forward a proposal for permanent rules on tokenized stock trading.

Between those points, the SEC will be gathering evidence. How automated market makers handle trading in tokenized shares, how the approved-user restriction works, and how issuers respond to seeing their stock on these venues will all feed into the drafting. Selway's hope of moving from exemption to rulemaking within about a year suggests the observation period will be short relative to the order's five-year life.

The main open questions are those he left unanswered: when final rules would follow a proposal, and whether tokenized derivatives will be included. The exemption remains in force in the meantime, covering only tokens with the full rights of the underlying shares.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY